Lapaas Digital

Author: lapaasindia

  • Paired Comparison Analysis- A tool for Decision Making

    Paired Comparison Analysis- A tool for Decision Making

    When you get some options and you have to choose the best one, how do you decide which one to choose? This in particular very challenging when your options are unique in contrast to each other and if the criteria based on which you have to take your decisions are subjective. Primarily we can take the help of the Decision Matrix, but for getting accurate results introduce the Paired Comparison Analysis.

    WHAT’S IN IT

    What is Paired Comparison Analysis?

    So, This tool helps you compare ideas in pairs. You have to compare one idea with the other and evaluate which of the 2 is better. Hence, it is a Paired comparison. 

    Note that this comparison is based on your view, all your current knowledge about the potential of both ideas. You may or may not have any actual data for your views, But at this stage, it is fine. 

    Paired Comparison, also known as Pairwise comparison has its uses in many fields like the scientific study of preferences, attitude, and voting system, etc.

    So, According to Wikipedia L. L. Thurstone, a well-known Psychometrician proposed a scientific approach using the Pairwise Comparison for measurements in 1927.

    Paired Comparison Chart

    Suppose you have 5 ideas and you want to select the best one. As seen in the chart write your ideas along the left-most column and again write all your ideas along the top row.

    Start with the smoothie idea on the horizontal row. I would compare it 1 by 1 with the ideas on the vertical columns. Remember that the score is for the idea on the horizontal row and what I will do is assign a value from -3 to +3. A score of 3 means that the idea in the horizontal row is much better than the idea on the vertical column.

    A score of 0 means that there’s not much of a difference in the quality of the ideas in the horizontal row to the vertical column and a score of -3 means that the idea in the horizontal row is much worse than the idea in the vertical column.

    The green boxes are where you input the scores. The grey boxes automatically show the corresponding score for the idea it is being compared to. 

    So let’s say I compared the smoothie idea to the cardboard furniture idea. I give it a score of 2 in the green box as this idea is better, but not dramatically better than the cardboard idea. The formula automatically gives a -2 in the row belonging to the cardboard furniture. It is exactly the opposite of the score I gave implying that it is worse than the smoothie idea. 

    The smoothie idea is then compared to the other ideas listed in the vertical column. So, then compared to the Bluetooth idea it is again given a score of 2. But when it is compared to the personalized tea idea it’s scored as 3 as the smoothie idea, in my opinion, is significantly better than the personalized tea idea. 

    Comparing

    When compared to the travel website I give it a score of 2 again. The opposite scores are also put in the grey boxes corresponding to those ideas.

    PAIRED COMPARISON ANALYSIS

    For example, as we have put 3 in the green box under the Personalized tea option, -3 is automatically put in the grey box corresponding to Personalized tea on the horizontal row. 

    These scores are not assigned based on any factors. I have assigned these scores based on my gut feeling or instinct. When you do a paired comparison analysis for the given ideas feel free to use your instincts. 

    Now, put all the other scores for all other choices accordingly. Then just add all the values in the same row. 

    For the smoothie row, the total value is 2+2+3+2= 9

    For the cardboard furniture row, the total value is -2+2+1+1= 2

    Also, Calculate the total values for Bluetooth sunglasses, personalized tea, and travel website.

    PAIRED COMPARISON ANALYSIS

    Now we can see the results. The smoothie idea wins with a wide margin. But to get a more accurate value, we may also use the Decision Matrix. 

    PAIRED COMPARISON ANALYSIS

    Suppose we want to judge these ideas based on six factors and create a Decision matrix chart accordingly.  To get the best score, we may add the total scores of different ideas we got from the Paired Comparison chart to the score of the Decision matrix chart. Now we can see the Smoothie idea is the best one.

    PAIRED COMPARISON ANALYSIS

    Advantages of Paired Comparison Analysis 

    Paired Comparison analysis has some specific advantages.

    The advantages are,

    1. It is easy to calculate.
    2. Also, It can be used when the priorities are not clear.
    3. It is especially found helpful where you have no objective data to depend upon.
    4. Applying this tool, we can easily identify the best option.

    Conclusion

    Paired Comparison analysis is one of the best tools concerned with decision making.  Be it a business decision or any other decision, It can be implemented to get the best possible outcome.

    Also You can read our blog on Prospect Theory- An analysis of decision under Risk and Uncertainty

    FAQ’s

  • Recognition Primed Decision (RPD)-For complex situations

    Recognition Primed Decision (RPD)-For complex situations

    Recognition primed decision (RPD) models are helping us to make quick decisions in critical situations. This decision is helping to identify a reasonable solution and to think about it immediately. This model is based on how you make quick decisions with your imagination.

    WHAT’S IN IT

    What is the recognition primed decision?

    recognition primed decision

    This model was developed by Gary Klein, It is a decision-making tool that helps you to make decisions in a complicated situation. Most firefighters tend to use this technique in a critical situation. This model helps us to select the first course of action that is not rejected. 

    All other models that you have studied previously also help you decide and collect information, evaluation, and choosing the best option, it takes time, but this model is helpful for you to make a quick decision. Firefighters don’t have time to compare between two options.

    So how to make the decision, firefighters use their experience to size up the situation. It is easy for someone to make a decision, who has an experience of 10, 20, or 30-years. They can make decisions in a short period using their expertise and knowledge

    On the other hand, an inexperienced leader can’t make a good decision compared to experienced people. People are not able to evaluate options because imagination is a key factor, which comes from experience. This mode tells us how do experienced people make decisions?

    Purpose of Recognition primed decision

    Following are the purpose of this decision

    1. Helps to make quick decisions

    This model is helping to make quick decisions. This model is helpful for firefighters to make a quick decision in a complicated situation.

    2. Help an experienced man in Decision Making

    This primed decision model helps an experienced person in decision making. It helps a knowledgeable person who has good experience handle the problem and solve it from its base.

    Where the recognition primed decision model is used?

    1. Fire ground commanders

    This decision model is mostly used by fire ground commanders in a panic situation. It helps an experienced person to make a quick decision in a complicated situation.

    2. Chess player

    This model is used in the sports industry and is also used by chess players, While playing chess the player must make quick and good decisions.

    3. Stock market traders

    recognition primed decision

    This model is also by stock market traders to make quick and effective decisions related to stocks.

    Limitation of Recognition primed decision model

    There is only one limitation of this model, i,e. to make a decision you need to have proper knowledge about the situation and causes of action. If there is one leader who is experienced, he/she has to take a proper decision then they can make one using this technique, but if you are in a group where everyone’s ideas are different, then it is difficult for that group to make a quick decision using this method. So, to use this method, you need have to have proper experience in the required field.

    3 variations of recognition primed decision model

    Following are the 3 variations of this decision model

    1. Variation 1

    In this variation, the decision-maker has understood the situation and the scenario where both details of situations and details of relevant causes of action are known. More experienced decision-maker has more knowledge and he can make a good decision using his experience.

    2. Variation 2 

    In this scenario, the decision-maker has to diagnose an unknown situation to choose from the known course of action. So, basically in this situation, the decision-maker knows about the course of action but lacks knowledge about the parameters of the situation. So, in this scenario, he/she has to understand possible details of the situation carefully and then choose the course of action.

    3. Variation 3

    In this scenario, a decision maker is well aware of the situation but unaware of the proper courses of action. So, in this situation, the decision-maker has to understand each course of action until a perfect course of action is not fit in the situation.

    Process of recognition primed decision model

    There is not any particular process available to make a decision but you can follow these steps to understand the model.

    1. First, you have to understand the whole matter and then you have to gather all the information in your mind, try to size up your situation.
    2. In this step, you have to use your whole experience and training to determine your actual problem.
    3. Now you have to identify cues and clues from the whole information, using your experience and knowledge.
    4. In this step, you have to prepare a mind game. This means now your brain is playing with you and it shows you various options, so you have to understand every option’s result.
    5. Now, choose the best option and make a decision.
    6. So in this step, you have to implement that option in your problem.
    7. Now evaluate that decision and check whether it is working properly or not.
    8. If your decision is not working properly then repeat this process from the start.

    Conclusion 

    A Recognition primed decision model helps you to make quick decisions in complicated situations. Firefighters, chess players, stock market traders are mostly using this technique to make a quick decision. This model tells us how experienced and knowledgeable people can make quick decisions easily. So to make a quick decision in a complicated situation, you need to have more experience in those situations.

    Also You can read Our blog on How Good Is Your Decision Making

    FAQ’s

  • Prospect Theory- An analysis of decision under Risk and Uncertainty

    Prospect Theory- An analysis of decision under Risk and Uncertainty

    Risks and Uncertainties are parts of our daily life. To do something big we always have to take risks. But how to make decisions under Risk and Uncertainty? Should we depend on our fate? To act better in such situations, we must self introspect. Yeah, you read it right! We have to know how our brain works. One such theory that helps us understand the basic human nature when it comes to making decisions under risk and uncertainty is the Prospect Theory.

    WHAT’S IN IT

    What is Prospect Theory

    According to Behavioral economics, Prospect theory is a conduct model that shows how individuals settle on options that include hazard and vulnerability (for example % probability of gain or loss). It shows that individuals think in terms of expected utility relative to a reference point as opposed to absolute results.

    Prospect theory was proposed by Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky in 1979 and was developed in 1992. Kahneman won the Nobel prize in economic sciences in 2002 for changing modern Economics forever by suggesting the Prospect Theory. 

    Kahneman wrote “Thinking Fast and Slow” a book on Economics that was recognized by the New York Times in 2011, as a bestseller, his book discusses decision making. 

    However, before we talk about prospects, we have to first discuss its predecessor, Utility Theory. Utility Theory was proposed in 1738 by the Swiss mathematician Daniel Bernoulli. It was known as a moral expectation opposing the theory of mathematical expectation until the mid 20th century.

    This theory explains why most people are risk-averse when it comes to making decisions that could result in a loss, especially in situations such as gambling. This theory is based on the assumption that everyone is rational and all the decisions that they will make.

    For example, suppose you have a choice to flip a coin. If it’s head you will get Rs 100, and if it’s tail you will get Rs 0. Another choice you have is Just taking Rs 50 without flipping the coin.

    UTILITY THEORY 

    According to Utility theory, people are more likely to choose to gain Rs 50 instead of choosing the uncertainty, although there was a chance to win more. 

    Utility theory focuses on the aspect of how useful the money is to you. A gain of Rs 1 means more to you than if you had Rs 1 crore and you gained Rs 1. Going back to the example of why people choose the option of getting Rs 50? because it has the highest utility since it carries no risk rather than the possibility of receiving double or nothing with a gamble.

    Prospector theory uses the same core concepts as Utility theory however, it includes an individual’s reference point in regards to decision making, for example of gambling. 

    Therefore, happiness can be determined by the recent change in their wealth due to their reference point. Reference points are important for later comparisons of their current and past wealth. 

    Prospect Theory is all about the individual’s gains and losses rather than the utility of their wealth. It indicates that we dislike losing more than we like winning. 

    Prospect Theory

    This is a graphical representation of the Prospect Theory. The curve in the upper right represents some gains, and the curve in the lower left represents losses. Looking at the curves on either side of the graph, we can see the decline on the left is steeper than the incline on the right. This indicates that losses are more salient than gains. 

    Examples of Prospect Theory

    In our regular life, we see a lot of examples of the Prospect Theory. Let me show some of them.

    The silver medal winner is never that happy because they lost the gold medal, but the bronze medalist is happy because they made it to the top three. 

    Prospect Theory

    The key difference between Prospect Theory and Utility Theory

    Now that we’ve gone over the general ideas of both utility and prospect theories, we’d like to highlight some of the key differences between the Prospect Theory and the Utility Theory. 

    First Utility Theory does not account for where you started from and how it will feel to shift from that point of view. For example, if you have Rs 1 crore and your friend has Rs 9 crore, and tomorrow you both have Rs 5 crore, how happy you both would be? 

    According to Utility Theory, both you and your friend will be equally happy tomorrow because you both have Rs 5 crore.

    However, if you look at the numbers, you can see that you will be much happier than your friend. Prospect Theory can predict this as it takes into consideration that you have gained Rs 4 crore, while your friend has lost Rs 4 crore. 

    Prospect Theory takes into account that people are not entirely rational. They do not make their choices based solely upon which choice has more utility but upon which choice is less aversive or causes them the least loss. 

    Conclusion

    Utility theory was used in Economics for over 3 centuries. Prospect theory has replaced it and changed the modern economy. This theory is applied today in fields like Politics, Software development, Business management, etc.

    Also you can Read Blog on How the Decision Cycle helps to make decisions

    FAQ’s

  • What is Decision Matrix Analysis?

    What is Decision Matrix Analysis?

    Should I subscribe to Netflix or Amazon Prime? Or should I eat chicken or veggies? Should I watch Football on ESPN or WWE on Ten Sports? Life is all about making decisions. We take most of our decisions immediately but in some cases, we take time and choose which option we have to go based on our gut feelings, which is ok. But you cannot make business decisions based on your gut feelings. As one wrong decision can finish your business in just one moment. So, That’s why good managers use some mathematical and statistical approaches to make decisions. They use several rules like Pareto Analysis, Decision Matrix, etc.

    WHAT’S IN IT

    What is Decision Matrix?

    Suppose you want to buy a car and you have 3 options. So, Now, you have to choose only one of them based on some criteria like cost, fuel economy, service, reliability. It can be tempting to opt for the lowest cost car. But, what if that car is not reliable at all? Would you still choose that one? So all the factors must be considered to make the best decision. This is complex.

    How can I solve this puzzle? The answer is the Decision Matrix. It’s a useful tool, where there are several options to be considered, but no obvious choice. It was invented by Stuart Plugh, is also known as Grid Analysis, Pugh Matrix Analysis, and Utility Theory. 

    When to use?

    Decisions matrices can be used to make complicated choices in no time.  Let me mention some uses of it.

    1. Whenever we have to choose the best option among multiple options.
    2. Whenever we have to decide based on multiple criteria.

    There are two kinds of matrices, Simple Decision Matrix and Weighted Decision Matrix.

    Simple Decision Matrix

    This is a sample chart of it. On the left column, we put the criteria based on which we are going to judge the options. On the top row from left to right, we put the options.

    As you see, there are 5 criteria. Let’s imagine a scale for rating the cars based on each criterion. Car A costs the least, So give its cost a rating of 5. But it has a below-average Practicality and Fuel Economy, So rate the Practicality and Fuel Economy with 2 for Car A. The performance of Car A is better than average, but not as good as that of Car C, so let’s rate the performance with 4. This car is the least reliable, So the reliability of Car A gets 1. 

    Similarly, rate the Car B and Car C based on these criteria. Now, simply calculate the total of all the ratings for each car. Car A gets 14, Car B gets 14, Car C gets 18. 

    Though Car A is the cheapest in terms of cost, after this analysis we know that we have to go with Car C.

    But all the criteria may not have the same importance. So here comes the Weighted Decision Matrix.

    Weighted Decision Matrix

    This is a Weighted Matrix chart.  Just like in Simple one, you have to put Criteria on the left column. Then keep the second column blank, and then from the third column to the top row put the options. Under every option create two columns, Score and Total. 

    Give every criterion a number rating according to its priority to you. Suppose Criteria 1 has the least priority for you and Criteria 5 gets the greatest priority, then give Criteria 1 a score of 1 and Criteria 5 a score of 5. Put these scores on the blank column after the criteria column. Name this column as Weighting.

    Just as we have learned before give every option ratings based on different criteria on the score columns under every option. Multiply the scores with the corresponding weightings and put those values under the “total” column under every option.

    Now, simply add all the values in the “total” column under every option. After following these steps you can choose the winner.

    Benefits of Decision Matrix

    There are several benefits of this Matrix and according to many management executives, this is the best tool for taking a complicated decision.

    There are also other tools of Decision making, like the Decision Tree or the Pareto Analysis. But Decision Matrix Is the easiest one, Anyone can use it and can choose the best option.

    Another advantage of this Matrix is purely based on Mathematics. So there is no scope for gut feelings here, which reduces the chance of human error. 

    Conclusion

    Decision Matrix helps us to make a rational choice from several familiar options. Several software like Rationalize.io and Ruminate.io are based on the Decision Matrix Analysis.

    Also you can read our blog on How Good Is Your Decision Making

    FAQ’s

  • TDODAR Decision Model- The Option Under Pressure

    TDODAR Decision Model- The Option Under Pressure

    TDODAR Decision Model is a decision-making tool, which can help us to make good decisions under pressure. This model tells us how to choose the best option in a panic situation when you have limited time and limited resources. There are lots of ways to make a decision, but in a pressured situation this model can help you to choose the best way.

    WHAT’S IN IT

    Concept of Decision Making

    Emotions and Decision Making: Five Steps to Improve Your Process | CFA Institute Enterprising Investor

    Decision making is a process to choose the best alternative options for your problem properly. The decision-making process is also known as a problem-solving tool. Because you will reach your solution, after choosing the best option for your problem through decision making.

    If you have information, proper time, good teamwork then you can make decisions through discussion in a proper manner and you can find out your solution easily. But if you want to find out the root cause of your problem then use Interrelationship Diagram (link this to another blog which I wrote, “interrelationship diagram-amazing problem-solving tool).

    What happens when you have to make decisions in a panic situation?. At this point, you don’t have lots of time to make decisions. Most of the people can give up on this point and they are not doing any action at that point. So, here the TDODAR decision model can help us to make decisions in a panic situation.

    What is the TDODAR Decision Model?

    TDODAR stands for:

    T= Time

    D= Diagnosis

    O= Option

    D= Decision

    A= Act

    R= Review

    This helps us to make better decisions in panic situations. Some people’s nature is very calm and cool, so they can handle pressure situations very easily. But most people’s nature is not calm and cool, so the TDODAR decision model can help them.

    This decision model is mostly used in the firefighter department. Because in that situation you need to focus and stay calm. This technique is also used in aeroplanes, by pilots in a panic situation. In mid-flight, any pressured situation happens, then the pilot can take decisions through this method.

    If you learn this TDODAR decision model then you can also apply this technique in your daily life in a pressured situation.

    Purpose of TDODAR Decision Model

    AAE - Reinventing Associations on Purpose

    Following are the purpose of TDODAR decision model

    1. Helps to decide in a pressured situation

    If your nature is not cool and calm and you can easily panic in a pressured situation, then the TDODAR decision model can help you to make the best decision in a pressured situation. The TDODAR decision model tells us how to make decisions in a panic situation when you don’t have much time and information.

    2. Useful for firefighter and pilots

    This decision model is mostly used by firefighters and pilots in pressured situations. This technique is very useful for firefighters when they are in a fire area. In this situation, they have to make quick decisions with available resources.

    In an aeroplane, not most times but whenever a panic situation happens, then pilots have to make the best decision and that time they can use the TDODAR decision model

    3. Make decisions in a limited time

    TDODAR decision model’s USP is, it is a very useful technique to make decisions when you have limited time and limited resources.

    Steps In TDODAR Decision Model

    TDODAR decision model runs on 6 steps that is Time, Diagnosis, Option, Decision, Act, Review. To understand this model you need to know these steps.

    1. Time 

    In the first step, you have to understand how much time you have to make decisions. If you have a lot of time then you can make decisions in the proper manner, but if you have a shortage of time, then you have to understand the situation and not get to panic. You can record time in someplace, so it reminds you of the value of time.

    2. Diagnosis 

    In this step, you need to collect all your resources, at that time available. The resources can be some people, some information related to problems. Better resources can help you to understand the problem properly. A group of people can help you in a better way than that of a single person. So, it is very necessary to collect all your resources.

    3. Option

    How Do You Trade Options?

    After collecting all resources you need to think of the best option, which can help you to solve your problem. In this stage, you have to think and consider maximum options, which can help you to solve problems

    4. Decide  

    Now, you have to take the decision of your option, from considering all options. Now you have to select the best option, which can solve your problem and agree on that option.

    For choosing the best option you have to ask all resources (persons) and also consider their opinion. But, in this situation, you have to remember who the decision-maker is. If you are a decision-maker then you can choose the best option, but if you are just a resource then you just considered your opinion.

    5. Act 

    After choosing the best option, now you need to take action on them. On this stage, you have to put your 100% on that option. Work can be divided between people, then everyone has to give their best.

    6. Review 

    In this stage, you have to assess your plan and have to check everything is going to be right. You have to assess that option you have chosen and that action you take in resolving your problem.

    If your plan is not going well that you decide, then you have to do these 6 steps again, and you have to choose another option and take action on that.

    Example of TDODAR Decision Model

    If you are a manager of a manufacturing company, and you have to finish your 500 bags order within 2 days. Out of 10 machines, your 5 machines are not working properly, because of bad maintenance. Now how do you make decisions using the TDODAR decision model?

    • Now, first, we understand we have only 48 hours to complete the order. 
    • Then after that, we ask other managers and take their opinion.
    • After considering other people we find out 4 options, 1. We can use only 5 machines and try our best. 2. We can try to repair machines, but it takes time. 3. We can only use 5 machines and will be doing overtime. Or 4. Rent 5 machines for 2 days.
    • After considering all options we will decide to choose the 4th option. In the 1st option, we cannot complete the whole work with only 5 machines. In the 2nd option, it takes a lot of time. And in the 3rd option, we can do overtime but it is not profitable.
    • After choosing our best option now we have to do the action.

    Conclusion

    The TDODAR decision model is a decision-making tool. This model helps to choose the best option under pressure. When you have limited time and limited resources then you can use this technique to make a decision. This decision model is mostly used by firefighters and pilots in panic situations. To understand this model you have to know 6 steps of this model and apply them.

    Also You can Read Our Blog on How To Make a Decision?

    FAQ’s

  • Vroom-Yetton Decision Model

    Vroom-Yetton Decision Model

    As a manager, you need to make lots of decisions at different levels for your business. Decision making is very necessary for any business to run a business for a long period.

    Every decision is not hard to take, managers can take some decisions at their level, but that will make him autocratic, but some decisions need to be discussed with your team member but this process is very time-consuming. Now, a big question stands in front of the manager, so here is a decision-making model available which is called VROOM-YETTON DECISION MODEL.

    WHAT’S IN IT

    Concept of the Vroom-Yetton decision model

    Vroom-Yetton decision model

    This concept was originally developed by Victor Vroom and Philip Yetton in their book (1973) “LEADERSHIP AND DECISION MAKING’ and later with Arthur Jago (1988).

    The Vroom-Yetton model is created to help us to find out the best decision-making approach and leadership style based on your current situation.

    This model says to us, no single decision-making process fits in every scenario. In this model Vroom and Yetton create a lot of situations for you to reach the best direction.

    This model also helps us to create consistency and also helps in collective decision-making style and individual decision-making style.

    This model is run on a flow chart, which helps to show how to take action on different kinds of situations in the decision-making process.

    Purpose of the Vroom-Yetton decision model

    Following are the purpose of this model;

    1. To identify the best decision-making approach

    The Vroom-Yetton decision model helps us to identify the best decision approach. This model tells us how to make decisions, with a team or without a team. If you want to need to make a decision, then you need to follow a proper approach, so this model is helpful to find out the best decision approach.

    2. Help to reach the best decision

    The Vroom-Yetton decision model runs on 7 questions, you just need to answer them yes or no and in the end, you will reach your best way of decision.

    In short, this model tells us that there are a lot of ways to reach your decision, but if you want to find the best route, then follow this model.

    3. Help to collective and individual decision making

    The Vroom-Yetton decision model creates a lot of options for you and it creates consistency. It also helps us in different kinds of situations. You can use this model for collective and individual decision making.

    3 factors of the Vroom-Yetton decision model

    To understand this model first you need to know the 3 main factors of this model.

    Following are the 3 main factors of this model.

    1. Decision quality

    Decision quality is the first main factor which affects your decision making. So, first, we understand, what is quality? Quality is considered as your resources. 

    Resources mean, how many people do you have for research? How much time do you have for research? How much information do you need? Or how much information do you have?

    These resources are directly impacting your quality decision. So, your resources must be good for your decision-making process because it shows your decision quality.

    2. Team commitment

    Team commitment is the second factor of this model, which directly impacts on your decision making.

    Some decisions have an impact on your team that is good. It’s best to collaborate with that team and take decisions because it improves your decision quality.

    But, sometimes decisions are not made impacting your team, so you don’t need to collaborate with them, because it directly affects your decision making.

    So, you need to understand this factor, while using The Vroom-Yetton decision model for your decision.

    3. Time constraints

    Time constraints mean, how much time do you have for taking a particular decision?

    If you have limited time, then you cannot involve your team member into a decision process. At that time you need to make decisions on your basis, as manager. 

    But, if you have lots of time, then you can collaborate with your team members and then you can make your decision.

    Leadership style

    Vroom-Yetton decision model

    There is a big role in leadership style in this Vroom-Yetton decision model. To understand this model, you need to know these 5 codes and apply them based on your current situation.

    Check out these 5 codes to understand this model.

    1. Autocratic 1 (A1)

    • In this type, leadership has its research or information, and he/she can make their own decision using that information. This type is autocratic.
    • Other team members’ opinions are not considered in this type.
    • In this case, you need to tell your decision to your team.

    2. Autocratic 2 (A2)

    • In this case, the manager collaborates with the team and collects information but he makes decisions alone.
    • In here may or may not be informed to team members about what the decision is taken.

    3. Consultative 1 (C1)

    • In this case, the manager collects the information with a person.
    • Teammates do not meet as a group and the manager can make alone decisions.

    4. Consultative 2 (C2)

    • In this case, the manager collects all teammates as a group and takes information from teammates with proper discussion.
    • Here teammates meet each other, and through discussions, they find out solutions.
    • Here the manager’s decision may or may not reflect the follower’s influence. So, teammates are involved in a group to help each other to make decisions.

    5. Group (G1)

    • In this case, the manager and teammates can discuss the problem.
    • The manager does not try to force his or her idea on other group members.
    • All the group can accept is an important factor in this situation.

    7 questions of the Vroom-Yetton decision model

    The Vroom-Yetton decision model depends on these 7 questions, now you just need to understand these questions, then I will show you how to use these questions for making the best decision.

    Question No. 1

    Is the quality of the decision important?

    Question No. 2

    Is team commitment to the decision important?

    Question No. 3

    Do you have enough information to decide on your own?

    Question No. 4

    Is the problem well structured?

    Question No. 5

    If you made the decision yourself, would the team support it?

    Question No. 6

    Does the team share organizational goals?

    Question No. 7

    Is conflict amongst the team over the decision likely?

    How the Vroom-Yetton decision model works

    Vroom-Yetton decision model

    To understand this model you just need to understand this chart of the Vroom-Yetton decision model.

    1. On the above diagram in the left-hand side, all 7 questions are placed and in front of every question, there is an option Y and N.
    2. Y stands for yes, and N stands for No.
    3. Now you have to just read the first question and answer them yes or no. If your answer is yes then follow to ‘Y’ and if your answer is no then follow ‘N’.
    4. Now you have to read the second question and you have to do the same things, choose your answer Y or N. and continue this process.
    5. At some time you will reach the end and find out one code.
    6. We will discuss these codes above.
    7. Now you have to read your code description.
    8. Now you will find out your effective answer.
    9. Choose this method to make a decision.

    Follow these methods for using this model.

    Conclusion

    The Vroom-Yetton decision model is good for everyone, who wants to make a good decision in a life or your business. It helps us to identify the best decision-making approach. This model tells us what actions are taken in a different kind of situation.

    Overall if you want to decide on your business or your life then follow this model, you will find out your best way, and also you will learn something new.

    Also You can Read Our Blog on How the Decision Cycle helps to make decisions

    FAQ’s 

  • How Good Is Your Decision Making

    How Good Is Your Decision Making

    Decision making is part of our lives, in both personal and professional life, we take a lot of decisions. This is not necessary, we always good in our decision making sometimes we make the wrong decision. Good decision making depends on what is your goal statement, if the decision you choose is relevant for your goal statement then it can become a good decision for you.

    WHAT’S IN IT

    What is good decision making?

    Good Decision Making. A decision is the product of choosing… | by A. A. ALEBRAHEEM | 5 Essential Dimensions | Medium

    In our daily life or our corporate life, we make a lot of decisions. Some of them become an effective decision and some of them become ineffective decisions. Thus, how to decide which is a good decision or what is good decision making?

    So, here we take an example;

    So, if you want to go on vacation and you have to choose the best travel agent for that so, how do you choose an agent, I think based on price and quality. If you find out the best travel agent in your budget and good quality then it can be your good decision.

    This is good for your goal statement then it can become a good decision making. For making a good decision you have to understand the whole options of your problem and have to analyse them carefully and then have to make decisions.

    Good decision-making skills

    In a different kind of situations, you need different kinds of skills. So, you have to understand which skills are required for taking a particular decision.

    1. Leadership quality

    For making a good decision you must have leadership quality. For a leader, it is hard to control the whole teammates, it is hard to manage teamwork. A good leader is always helpful to business to grow up. For a leader, it is necessary to maintain a good relationship with your teammates.

    2. Problem-solving ability

    Problem-solving ability is not only good for a corporate but also helpful in personal life. Making a good decision is necessary to you have a problem-solving ability. Problem-solving ability is developed from your experience. Experienced people can make good decisions using their problem-solving ability skills.

    3. Time management

    Time management is also a useful skill which has to use by leaders to make a good decision. For making any good decision it is necessary to understand how much time do you have? or how much time did it take to collect information regarding problems? In short, leaders have to understand how to manage time in different kinds of situations and make effective decisions.

    4. Thinking skills

    For making good effective decision leaders must have better-thinking skills. A great thinker can handle a difficult situation in difficult times. A great thinker can show you the best way of choice making.

    5. Communication skills

    How to Improve Communication Skills? – Career Prospectus

     You not only have good leadership quality but you also have to good communication skills, for making good choices with your teammates. Communication skills help you to collaborate with your members and make good choices.

    6. Listening quality

    For making a good choice leader must have the listening ability, which means he has to understand other team members information and also considered that information for making choices. If the leader is confused about some information then he can listen, other members opinions on that situation.

    Benefits of good decision making

    Following are the benefits of good decision making;

    1. Improve your confidence

    If you make a big choice for the first time and it will successfully implement in your life then next time whenever you want to make a choice you can make a choice easily. A good choice can improve your confidence and improve your leadership.

    2. Gives experience

    A good and bad both choices give you experience in your life. You can learn from that experience and implement those experience in your life, whenever you are facing a problem.

    3. Help to solve a problem

    A good choice is to always help you to solve problems. 

    4. Save time and money

    A good choice is to always help you to save time and money. Because if you make an ineffective choice then after a result you will realize you waste your time and money also.

    How to make a good decision

    Using the following steps you can make good decisions;

    1. Understand your vision

    For making any particular v first you have to understand your goal statement or vision. Your every choice is always related to your goal statement. While making a good choice you have to always remember what you want as a result.

    2. Collect related information

    After understanding your vision of the statement, now you have to collect all the relevant information about your problem. This is a long take process of choice making. You can also get help from your teammates to collect information related to the problem. 

    3. Choose options

    After collecting all information now you have to decide which options are helpful for you to solve this problem, analysed those options and collect them all. In this stage, you also get the help of your teammates.

    4. Make a decision

    Now you have a lot of options for your problem-solving. So now you have to choose the best option which can help you to solve this particular problem, in this step you also considered with your teammates and make your best choice.

    5. Take action

    Take action - Scrawny To Brawny

    After choosing your best option now you have to implement that option in the problem. in short, now you have to choose your option.

    Conclusion 

    A good choice is to always help you to solve your problem and a bad choice is always gives you experience. To make a good choice you always have to understand your goal or vision and then choose the best choice and take action. If you are an experienced person about your problem then it is very easy to make a choice. If you are in a group then your leader must have to be good to make a choice.

    Also you can Read our blog on How To Make a Decision?

    FAQ’s 

  • How To Make a Decision?

    How To Make a Decision?

    Every problem has a solution you just need to make a good decision for that problem. Decision making is a tough situation for someone, some people are not good at decision making and they don’t have any idea about how to make decisions. So here I give you some tips about how to make good decisions. Check this out.

    WHAT’S IN IT

    How To Make Decisions Using Decision Cycle?

    Essential Steps To Making Better Data-Informed Decisions

    Decision cycle is steps of actions on a repeated basis, which helps you to make the best decision. There are lots of decision cycles available in the world for different kinds of fields. Every field uses different kinds of decision cycles. Means, a research basis decision cycle is not useful for making your personal life decisions or managerial decision cycle is not helpful to you to make decisions for doing any research.

    So, for using the decision cycle first you need to understand which field is your or to understand which decision cycle is fit for your scenarios.

    Some decision cycles examples

    1. PDCA

    PDCA stands for Plan-Do-Check-Act. You can use this technique for choosing big decisions in your life. You can also use this cycle for business decisions but you have to understand your problem first.

    2. OODA

    OODA stands for Observe-Orient-Decide-Act. This technique is mostly used by militants in war situations. This technique is developed by Air force retired Colonel John Boyd. He also uses this technique in aerial combat.

    3. Herbert Simon model

    The Herbert Simon model is also a decision-making model. This model is used by management; you can also use this technique for daily life problems.

    4. Scientific method

    This method is used by scientists for doing research.

    To understand this decision cycle in detailed click here.

    How To Make Decisions Between Two Options?

    People are always confused between two options. It is very difficult to choose one option between the two. But if you think deeply about both options then you can realise it’s not hard. Mostly in this situation, you are confused when both the choices are equally right for you. So in this situation, it is harder to make a choice.

    So, how to choose between two options? In this situation, you have to accept the option which is favourable for you and reject the option which is unfavourable for you. Now you say everybody knows that favourable and which is unfavourable for you. So your choice should be based on what is your Goal Statement? 

    Just ask this question for you when you’re confused between two options, you will get your favourable option. Choosing between two options, identify which option is helping you to make a path for your Goal Statement.

    Decision Tree

    What is a Decision Tree? | Displayr

    What is a Decision Tree?

    A decision tree is a diagram, which looks like a tree used to determine a course of actions, every branch of the tree represents the possible situations. This also helps you make choices. A decision tree is very simple to understand and visualise. It shows what is going on. For making a decision tree you have to make a little effort for data preparation. It can handle both numerical and categorical data.

    How to create a decision tree

    Using an example now we understand how to make a decision tree.

    Example of a decision tree

    A new company is formed, which gives loans to the public, now they want to do marketing, but they don’t have any idea about their target audience. To find out the target audience of that company using a decision tree.

    From the above diagram, we categorized our audience in ages below 20, 20-50 and 50+. So from the first branch, we understand, up to 20 age, only 1% of people are taking a loan. In the 20-50 age range, 40% of people take a loan and above the 50 age, only 5% of people take a loan. From this basis now we are targeting 20-50 age groups.

    So, two parts happen again in 20-50 age people, which is married and unmarried. In this branch, we understand 55% of married people take most loans and only 15% of unmarried people take a loan.

    There are also two categories happening in married people, that is which have kids and which one has not kidding. The 75% married and which have kids take a loan and only 25% married which don’t have kids take a loan.

    So, from the above diagram, we understand our audience, which is 20-50 age people who are married and having kids.

    How To Make Decisions For Business?

    Business choices are always complicated for a manager to make perfect choices. There are always ups and downs in business and you have to tackle every situation in the proper way using the best choice. But, there are lots of techniques available in the market for business problems, you can also use those techniques. There are not any particular steps available in the world which can give you 100% result in decision making, but at least you have to use those steps in business just to understand the way of problem solutions.

    Steps of business decisions

    1. Understand your Goal or Vision statement

    Every company or business has their own goals or vision. For making every choice, first, you have to understand your goals or vision and then take an important choice of business which can help you to reach our goals or your vision.

    2. Gather useful information

    After understanding your problem you have to collect all information about that problem which can help you to solve problems. You can also consider your team and collect information from those. This research technique takes a lot of time to collect information because this is the base of your problem solution.

    3. Choose relevant options

    After collecting all information you have to analyze the whole information and understand which information is helpful to you to make a choice. So you have to collect all options which helps you to solve a problem.

    4. Make a decision

    From those options, now you have to select the best option which can solve your problem. In this stage again you have to understand your goal or vision and then make a choice. 

    5. Action 

    After making a choice, apply them on problems.

    How To Make Quick Decisions?

    June 2013 - Tip of the Month — The Catching Camp

    In this 21st century, everyone wants a quick result in their life. There is not any concept available which can help you to make quick choices. You can make quick choices about your daily problem like what to wear today? Which movie should I watch today?

    But in other kinds of problems, you can make quick choices but you have to think about it and it takes time. So, how to make a quick choice.

    For taking a quick choice you have to understand the best situation and worst situation of all options that you have. If you have two options then understand the best and worst situation of both options. If you are ready for both situations of one option then choose that option. And, if you are not ready for both scenarios or you are ready for good and not ready for bad situations then don’t accept it.

    Let’s take an example

    Should I join a corporate job or start a new business? This is a question, so let’s understand this problem.

    So, if you choose yes, what is the best scenario of that option; you can live your whole life easier and what is the worst-case scenario of this; every day you have to work hard and enjoy your whole life on weekends. So, if you are ready for both situations then accept this option.

    If you choose business then what is the best scenario of this option; if you start a business then you can become millionaire or billionaire. What is the worse scenario of this; your business model can fail. If you are ready for both scenarios then choose this.

    Conclusion 

    Decision making is a very useful technique in our daily life and corporate life. There are lots of steps available to make a good choice. You have to understand which decision cycle is fit for your problem. Not every choice you make needs to be always right. Sometimes it is not helpful to you. Now in this situation, you have to learn from your mistakes and share your experience with others so they can not make that mistake. 

    Also You can Read our Blog on How the Decision Cycle helps to make decisions

    FAQ’s

  • How the Decision Cycle helps to make decisions

    How the Decision Cycle helps to make decisions

    Decision cycle is steps, which is based on a repeated basis which helps you to reach the best solutions. It is a process of actions which can help you to find out the best solution for your business or your daily life problems. In the decision cycle, there are a lot of steps available, you need to follow each step for the best result.

    WHAT’S IN IT

    What is the Decision Cycle?

    The Decision Cycle and Outline of Its Steps | Download Scientific Diagram

    Decision Cycle is a step of action used on a repeated basis, which helps you to make decisions and solve problems. For taking decisions you have to follow some actions properly and then you have to make decisions. This whole process is called a decision cycle.

    Every field has different kinds of decision cycles. All fields do not use a one specific decision cycle, so you need to understand which is your field and which decision cycle is fit for you for taking particular decisions.

    Examples of Decision Cycle

    (A) PDCA Cycle

    PDCA this concept was first developed by The American statistician and physicist Walter Shewhart. Later William Deming developed this model by inspiring Walter Shewhart’s model.

    PDCA stands for (Plan-Do-Check-Act). This is a four-step management process used for solving business problems or other management problems. This decision cycle is also known as the Deming Cycle, Shewhart cycle and PDSA (Plan-Do-Study-Act).

    PDCA or PDSA is a step to help you to improve your product and services. It is a systematic decision cycle used by management and doing a test on different kinds of projects.

    When to use PDCA Cycle

    1. When starting a new improvement project

    If you want to start a new project and don’t have any idea where to start? Then, following this cycle will help you to find the best route for your project.

    2. Developing a new design for your product or service

    If you want to develop your design of product or services then you can use this decision cycle.

    3. For continual improvement

    If you are doing continuous improvement for your business then use this decision cycle for best solutions.

    4. Implement new changes

    If you want to implement new changes then you can use this decision cycle for better results.

    Steps of PDCA Cycle

    5 Simple Steps to Creating Exceptional How-To Content
    1. Plan 

    This is the first step of the PDCA Cycle. In this step, first, you need to form a proper team which can help you to make a plan. After forming a team now you need to identify the problem with the help of your other teammates and you have to understand the problem.

    After understanding the problem, now you need to identify the potential root cause of that problem. You also need to develop hypotheses about issues.

    2. Do

    In this second step, you have to describe the solution and also have to try that solution on a small basis on a pilot project and you have to also measure what result comes from that. While doing a test on a pilot project you also have to understand what is useful and what is unuseful for your main project.

    3. Check

    In this step, you have to study the result, which comes from your pilot project. You also have to measure the effectiveness of your result. You can also communicate with other teammates and get feedback from them for better results.

    4. Act 

    In this stage, you have to take action with your solution. If your solution was successful then you can implement it, but if your solution is not effective then you can again use the PDCA decision cycle.

    (B) OODA Loop Decision Model

    The OODA loop, and its relation to SA and decision making (adapted from... | Download Scientific Diagram

    OODA loop is a decision-making process of human reaction time. Full form of OODA is Observe, Orient, Decide, and Act. The OODA loop method is created by Air force retired Colonel John Boyd. he uses this method when he is on his mission of aerial combat and it helps him to make decisions. This technique is mostly used by militants.

    Steps of the OODA Loop decision model

    1. Observe 

    Now in the first step, you have to observe, what is happening? Observe the whole area and to understand what’s going on. Observation is a key point in this process. From observing, you can easily identify the problem and understand the whole environment.

    Basically, in observation, you need to see trouble before it. Colonel John Boyd also saw trouble before it formed.

    2. Orient 

    After observing there are lots of options open in front of you. In this step, we have to decide if we are going to do something and why we are going to do it. In this step, you have collected a lot of options.

    3. Decide 

    In this stage, you have to decide the best option, which can solve your problem or you have to identify the best reaction which can help you.

    4. Act 

    After choosing your best option now you have to act on that. If it does not work properly then again start from observing and use this decision cycle again.

    Example of the OODA Loop Decision Model

    Imagine if you are at home and watching a horror movie and suddenly a noise comes from somewhere. Now in this situation, you first look around and observe your room. Now lots of thoughts come to your mind like, a dog is surrounded outside or it’s just wind or it’s just an illusion. After considering all thoughts you decided to see what sound actually is, so you go to the window and check there, then you find out it is the wind which makes noise.

    (C) Herbert Simon Decision Making Model

    According to the Herbert Simon Decision model, there are 3 ways to solve a problem which is Intelligence, Design, and Choice. For making a good decision these 3 steps can help you to solve problems. This is also the best decision cycle for you to taking your decisions.

    Steps of Herbert Simon Decision Model

    1. Intelligence

    The first step of the Herbert Simon Model is intelligence. In this stage, you need to understand the problem. Means which problem do want to make a decision. In this stage, you also have to collect information regarding problems.

    2. Design  

    In this stage, you have to identify how many possible solutions you have to solve this problem and select them. In short, if a problem is raised and you find out 5 best options for solving this problem from the whole information then only select those options.

    3. Choice 

    The choice is the third and last stage of this model. In this last stage, you have to select the best choice for your problem and implement it. Means out of the 5 you have to select the best option which can solve your problem.

    Example of Herbert Simon Decision Model

    If you are the manager of a manufacturing department and there is water leakage, it will happen in the pipe. Now using this model first you understand your problem and that is leakage. after collecting information we understand that there are 4 solutions available for this, 1. Use gum for leakages and fix it. 2. Change the whole pipe. 3. Put the bucket under the pipe 4. Switch off the water supply.

    Now we choose the 1st option which is to use gum and fix the leakage, in the 2nd option it is very costly to change the whole pipe, the 3rd option is a temporary solution and water is the most important part for manufacturing so the 4th option is also not fair for us.

    (D) Scientific Method

    Scientific Method ( Read ) | Biology | CK-12 Foundation

    This method is used by scientists for making decisions. The scientific method is also done in 4 stages which is Observation-Hypothesis-Experiment-Evaluation.

    The scientific method gives proper knowledge, which helps you to make decisions. In the scientific method, you have to do lots of experiments and have to identify which is the best solution for your problem and apply them. This is a very long process of decision making, because in this process you have to do lots of experiments, and you also have to present hypotheses.

    Steps of the scientific method

    1. Observations 

    In this first stage, you have to observe which problem you want to solve. Means, on which topic you have to want to do research. Then you have to collect all the information about that problem. You can also study the previous report to understand the whole information.

    2. Hypotheses 

    After collecting all information you have to analyse what is happening after using this information or what happened when we use another information or what result comes when we use all information or what happened when we use another research technique. You have to make predictions about the results in different kinds of scenarios.

    3. Experiment 

    Now you have a lot of scenarios, so then use every single scenario and experiment them and to analyse what result happened. This is a very long process that takes a lot of time for research.

    4. Evaluation 

    The last stage of this process is evaluation. After experimenting all scenarios you have to evaluate every scenario and choose the best one from that which can help you to solve the problem, if not a single scenario helps you then again start from observation and use this process again.

    Conclusion

    Decision making is a process which helps us to find out the best option for our problems. The decision cycle is steps of action to reach the best way. There are lots of decision-making models in the world which can help you to solve problems. You have to understand which model is useful for your field or for you to make decisions. So, understand every model of the business cycle and apply them in your life.

    Also you can read our blog on Interrelationship diagram – Amazing Problem Solving Tool

    FAQ’s

  • Interrelationship diagram – Amazing Problem Solving Tool

    Interrelationship diagram – Amazing Problem Solving Tool

    We face a lot of issues and problems in daily life, which are related to each other. So interrelationship diagram helps us to solve those problems. Basically, interrelationship diagrams are a tool to identify the root cause of any problem. 

    Also, This is a diagram, which shows how different kinds of problems are related to each other. It also helps to solve problems in a creative way and it also shows the causes and effects of all issues.

    WHAT’S IN IT

    What is an interrelationship diagram?

    Interrelationship digraph (network diagram) | Six Sigma Study Guide

    This is also known as 7 new QC tools or 7 new management tools. Interrelationship diagrams help us to think in multiple ways rather than linearly. 

    Hence, An interrelationship diagram is a tool to identify the root cause of any problem. It is a very useful tool for individuals and businesses. Using this technique, you can easily understand how multiple issues are related to the problem and influence each other.

    An Interrelationship Diagrams presents the issues in boxes and all boxes are connected to each other by arrows. Arrows are considered as a cause and effect relationship between problems. The cause with the highest number of outgoing arrows will be known as the root cause.

    How to create an interrelationship diagram?

    Use the following method to make an Interrelationship diagram

    1 Identify the problem

    In an interrelationship diagram first, you need to identify your problem and add this to the top of the page as a heading.

    2 identify issues

    After identifying problems you need to identify issues of your problem by brainstorm. Add these issues inboxes.

    3 identify cause and effect relationship

    Now you need to connect these issues by arrows. In this stage, you need to decide which is a cause and what are the effects. Means you need to compare every issue to each other and identify its effect and do an arrow pointing from cause to effect to show the relationship.

    4 identify intensity

    In this stage, you need to identify intensity. Means, observe every issue and count every outgoing arrow of every issue and count every outgoing arrow of every issue. Most outgoing arrow issues are known as your root cause. From this technique, you can identify the root cause of your problem.

    5 Take actions against high intensity

    Now you know your high-intensity problem and you reach your root cause. So, finally, you need to take action against all these high-intensity problems.

    Interrelationship diagram example

    interrelationship diagram

    Followings are the issues that are affected by a ‘POOR PRODUCT QUALITY’

    From the help of the above steps, we create this interrelationship diagram.

    • From the above diagram first, we understand our main problem which is poor product quality.
    • Now we find out our issues related to our problem and identify our issues, now we need to arrange them into boxes or circles.
    • After arranging the issues we need to compare every issue to each other and we need to find out every issue’s cause and effect relationship.
    • You need to point arrows from cause to effect, means while comparing every issue you need to arrow them, means which issue is effect to other issues.
    • After pointing all arrows, now we count every issue’s arrows, mean’s incoming and outgoing arrows.
    • Now, here we are finding out an outdated plant and machinery issue has most outgoing arrows and interrelationship diagram’s rule is, ‘most outgoing arrows issue is your root cause.’
    • So, from the above diagram, we find out our root cause of the problem. It’s also known as a key driver of a problem.
    • Now, we need to take action against that issue and we need to solve the issue as much as possible.

    Interrelationship diagram for business

    Every business faces a lot of problems in their earlier stage, and it is very hard to solve all problems, so here is a tool with available interrelationship diagrams, which can help you to find out the root cause of your problem.

    Interrelationship diagram is part of 7 management tools. Basically, it is a problem-solving tool. If you want to know the root cause of any business problem, then use this tool you will find out your answer. 

    It also shows you the cause and effect relationship of problem issues. It also helps to understand how different kinds of problems are connected to each other. 

    You can also use this technique in your personal life to find out the main reason for your problem, but mostly this technique is used in business. This is very cheap and time-saving techniques to find out the main reason behind your problem.

    This technique does not give you a solution but it gives you direction. You need to take action on your root cause and implement your best decision on that.

    Conclusion

    If you want to solve your daily life problem or your business problems then an interrelationship diagram is the best tool, which can help you to identify your root cause. It is a very easy technique for any person to use. You just need to do some practice of this technique. Try this technique and implement it in your life, you will learn something new.

    Also You can read our blog on Organizing ideas & Info into Common Themes

    FAQ’s